The Creative Personality Defined
Creativity researcher Frank Barron says, “The creative person is more primitive and more cultured, more destructive and more constructive, crazier and saner, than the average person” (Harman & Rheingold, 1984).
In other words, a creative person is paradoxical. He or she is also eclectic, quixotic, and mercurial, making it as difficult to pigeonhole and, thus, it's as difficult to define the creative personality as it is to define abstracts like the concept of truth.
For example, creative individuals can look at colors and shapes, as well as relationships, ideas, and problems, and then wonder, "What if I look at this from a different angle? What if I try this new method instead of doing it the way it's always been done?" And from this spontaneous toying and exploration, creative individuals find new and innovative ways to make something, to accomplish a task, to solve a problem, to express an idea, or to adapt to a situation. (Harman & Rheingold, 1984)
The ability to imagine and, therefore, create mental images of things and situations that are different from ordinary reality has long been recognized as the major trait of a creative mind, for it seems that highly creative people are more adept at seeing images in their mind's eye.
The problem is that such statements have the effect of making people doubt the quality of their creative abilities. As a result, they become increasingly timid and hesitant even to try to express themselves creatively; and, after a while, they become so insecure they conform to established ways of thinking, as well as the expectations of others. When this occurs, they have surrendered an important part of themselves, and that is the “vital and dynamic core” of their personalities better known as their creativity (Chaffee, 2002).
So in order to become more creative, a person must open his mind to the possibility of breakthrough insights and stop doubting the ability to create. In other words, one must regain contact with the little child who still dwells inside of them and has never lost the ability to create entire make-believe worlds out of almost nothing.
The Psychoanalytical Theory of Creativity
The main proponents of this theory include Freud, Jung, Kris, Rank, Adler, and Hammer; and the general argument is that people become creative in reaction to difficult circumstances or repressed emotions. For example, as Freud maintained, people repress memories of traumatic episodes or events, and the emotions related to these events are released through creative outlets.
The theory also argues the following:
- People are able to demonstrate creativity when they link the personal unconscious with the collective conscious.
- Regression precedes creativity.
- Feelings of inferiority contribute to creativity.
Arguably, however, other theorists maintain that the psychoanalytic theory lacks credence because it fails to take into consideration that people are both biological and social beings.
The Mental Illness Theory of Creativity
The proponents of this theory include Briggs, Eisenman, Goodwin, Jamison, Richards, and Martindale; and the major tenet is that some type of mental illness is actually necessary in order for people to be creative, even if that illness is exceptionally mild.
Studies have shown that the mental disorders most frequently associated with increased creativity are bipolar and manic-depressive syndromes, where sufferers undergo extreme mood swings that perhaps contribute to enhanced creative expression.
Of course, it’s interesting to note that many other theorists argue that mental illness actually interferes with and even prevents creativity and while, granted, some highly creative individuals do suffer from some form of mental disorder, the majority of highly creative individuals do not suffer from any form of mental disorder at all.
Eysenck’s Theory of Psychoticism
The main proponent of this theory was the late Hans Eysenck, who argued that highly creative individuals possessed a quality termed "psychoticism" – a disposition for psychotic tendencies. Eysenck also maintained that these psychotic tendencies were the foundation for creative personalities, and he developed a word-association test to measure a person’s psychoticism, with results correlated to form a continuum, ranging from psychotic through average and from conventional to highly social to altruistic.
Other theorists, however, for example, Rothenburg, disagreed with Eysenck and argued that his theory relied too heavily upon the results of the test he himself developed and, more seriously, that Eysenck had designed the test specifically to support his theory, which invalidated the results.
The Addiction Theory of Creativity
The main proponents of this theory are Lapp, Collins, Izzo, Norlander, Gustafson, and Wallas; and its major tenet is that addiction, for example, to drugs and/or alcohol, contributes to and even causes creativity.
This theory, however, is not largely supported by the mainstream research community, but instead by independent researchers, as well as by some creative personalities who themselves suffer from addiction problems. In fact, Lapp, Collins, and Izzo conducted a placebo study with 114 male volunteers, giving half tonic water and half vodka, and found that the amount of alcohol consumed did not increase a person’s creativity. (Dacey & Lennon, 1998)
On the other hand, it is interesting to note that the members of the study who simply thought they were intoxicated were the most creative of the entire group; and, in brief, although theorists have found there is often a correlation between addictive behavior and creativity, studies have not supported the argument that addiction either causes or contributes to creativity.
The Humanistic Theory of Creativity
The main supporters of this theory include Maslow, Rogers, and Fromm, though the theory is based mainly upon Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, a theory he developed, which maintains that humans have six basic needs that must be met in order for them to thrive and reach maximum potential.
People’s lower needs, however, must be met in order for them to progress to the next highest level, and only upon reaching the uppermost level, self-actualization, where needs are related to purpose and identify, are they at last free enough and comfortable enough to express themselves creatively.
The supporters of this theory argue that environment is unimportant because even the most difficult of environments cannot hinder creativity if someone possesses the ability to self-actualize and, thus, obtain the highest level, where he or she can choose to be creative. In other words, people decide for themselves whether or not they will be creative.
It's interesting to note that the Humanistic Theory is the one theory with which few people find fault, perhaps because it makes perfect sense that a person cannot concentrate upon creative endeavors unless his or her most basic and primal needs have first been met.
In conclusion, debate over what exactly makes one person more creative than another continues and will continue for a long time to come because, while there are many suppositions offering plausible explanations, there are yet no definitive answers and probably never will be.
Readers who found this article interesting may also enjoy reading “How to Become More Creative.”
Reference:
- Dacey, J., Lennon, K. (1998) Understanding Creativity: The Interplay of Biological, Psychological, and Social Factors. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
No comments:
Post a Comment